No cover for owners who are developers, court rules
The NSW home builders’ warranty insurer does not have to cover work for individuals who are classified as property developers, the state’s Supreme Court has ruled.
The decision means the NSW Self Insurance Corporation (SICorp) need not pay out on a builder’s policy to cover a contract with five members of the extended Succar family.
In March last year, the five won a $3.76 million payment from builder Dominium Homes over construction of a 10-unit residential building. They then sought to claim on the SICorp policy when the builder went into liquidation.
SICorp rejected the claim on the basis each of them was a “developer” and excluded under the Home Building Act.
The court has upheld that decision.
It heard that in 2017, the five signed a contract with Dominium to construct the building at Rosehill in Sydney. Dominium bought cover with SICorp.
By 2022 there was a dispute over the builder’s performance and the owners terminated the contract. The builder’s licence was suspended in 2023.
Justice Peter Brereton says the SICorp policy is “essentially back-up cover where recovery cannot be secured from the builder”, and it states the policy does not cover a claim by any person who is a developer.
The Succars argued they were not developers because in 2016 they had signed a deed of partition that divided the units between them, and once the building was completed there would be a formal subdivision and registration of a strata plan.
But Justice Brereton agrees with SICorp, which said whatever happened after the building was finished, until that time the five Succars owned all 10 dwellings, and that made them developers.
The construction remains unfinished.
Justice Brereton says the outcome may seem harsh, because the Succars have suffered a loss that the Home Building Act seeks to protect.
However, the act protects homeowners by imposing statutory warranties on builders and developers.
The five owners would end up with 10 units and it is reasonable to suppose some of them would sell a unit.
That purchaser would then have the benefit of statutory warranties against the five as the developers.
“That is the kind of beneficial outcome that is contemplated by the Home Building Act,” the judge said.
Read the judgment here.