Brought to you by:

Mutual demand ‘holds up’ despite soft market

Discretionary mutuals are thriving even as commercial insurance rates decline, Picnic Labs CEO Charles Pollack says.

Picnic, which recently celebrated 10 years of business, has launched seven discretionary mutuals tailored to their members.

“There’s certainly a saying that mutuals are born in a hard market ... but we’re still seeing solid growth in all the mutuals that we manage. Pretty much all our mutuals have extremely high retention rates, well into the 90s,” Mr Pollack told insuranceNEWS.com.au.

“Members are seeing protection that is still cost-effective relative to what others are willing to offer. In a soft market, you could argue that’s fairly surprising, but it comes back to the value proposition of a mutual ... providing tailored solutions and innovative integrations, as well as stability through the cycle.”

Picnic mutuals include Our Ark, which has more than 400 members and protects $8 billion in property around Australia; Farm Shield, which offers crop protection for WA farmers; and River City, which caters to high-rate clients with risks such as hazardous materials and expanded polystyrene.

Products come with features that are unavailable elsewhere. For example, faith organisations, community housing and small or neglected sectors such as ride-share can access international markets.

“The mutual can go out there and take advantage of this soft market with favourable reinsurance buying ... it can play in areas where the local insurance market just doesn’t want to go.”

Mr Pollack says mutuals were granted reductions ahead of market at renewals in recent years because “reinsurers like what they’re doing and want to support them”.

Ark Mutual is getting “very, very good support year on year" on the back of good claims experience.

“The reinsurers are really cutting a break ... They like clients that do what they say they’re going to do.”