Microsoft outage ‘shows need to understand accumulation risk’
Accumulation exposure has emerged as a major challenge for insurers as they assess the claims impact from the outage to Outlook email and other Microsoft 365 tools last week.
Australian businesses were among the worst affected when access to the US tech giant’s 365 apps were disrupted for hours, and one analyst estimates the incident could cause insured losses from $US300 million ($442.72 million) to $US500 million ($737.87 million).
Cyber specialist Emergence Insurance’s CEO Troy Filipcevic says the main issue arising from the outage is concentration risk.
The Microsoft crash and the CrowdStrike incident in 2024 exposed the same underlying concern for insurers, he notes.
“Thousands of policyholders can be affected simultaneously by the failure of one widely used technology provider,” Mr Filipcevic told insuranceNEWS.com.au.
“For cyber insurers, these incidents reinforce the importance of understanding accumulation exposure across cloud providers, software platforms and security vendors, rather than assessing each insured in isolation.”
Whether policyholders are covered for disruption caused by last week’s incident will depend on insurance contract wordings and policy triggers.
“There has clearly been significant economic disruption, but that does not mean every affected business will have an insured claim,” Mr Filipcevic said.
“Coverage will depend on whether the policy includes non-malicious system failure and outages of third-party technology providers, whether the waiting period was exceeded, and whether the business can demonstrate an actual loss of revenue/profit or necessary additional cost.”
Infosure director Andrew Brett said: “Just because you have cyber insurance, [it] doesn’t mean this event will be covered.”
For those with cyber cover, “it’s a really good time to go back and check through your policy wordings or ask your broker”.
Cyber expert Benjamin Di Marco says while there will be claims, policyholders must still demonstrate they have suffered “measurable loss, and also a loss that doesn’t just extend the waiting period, but it’s also over their financial deductibles … those are things that may mean the ultimate loss to the market isn’t as catastrophic as it could have been.”
A longer-term impact from the incident may be a change in how the industry assesses coverage of such events.
Mr Di Marco says the Microsoft incident “brings back a lot of the previous issues … with what widespread impact events might mean for cyber liability policies.
“I think you will see carriers looking at how they underwrite … [and] also some of the covers that they will do. And I think [it] would be particularly interesting to watch what happens with system failure cover, where things like waiting periods and deductibles go.”
Reinsurance broker Marsh Re says cyber policies will typically respond to contingent business interruptions arising from third-party vendor outages, whether accidental or malicious.
On the 365 apps outage, Marsh Re said: “From an accumulation perspective, Microsoft’s market dominance highlights the potential for a cyber systemic event to arise from disruption to this single point of failure risk.
“Overall, however, the impact on the insurance market is expected to be minimal, given the uneven nature of the disruption and likelihood that most losses will be limited to short-term productivity and operational delays.”