Stress test reveals risk management weaknesses
A reverse stress test by New Zealand’s central bank found life insurers are chiefly exposed to pandemic-linked sudden rises in death and illness claims, and disruption to reinsurance.
Five life insurers accounting for more than 70% of the market’s premium took part in the exercise, which presented severe but plausible scenarios that would leave them with less capital than the regulatory minimum.
Pandemic featured in four life insurer scenarios, involving severe mortality and morbidity stresses, and reinsurance disruption featured in several of the participants’ modelling, examining reinsurer failure, reduced availability of cover or other stresses.
Cyberattack was another risk in the test, which also involved three heath insurers.
“The exercise highlighted resilience of participating life and health insurers, with entities needing to model a combination of severe shocks to breach their solvency requirement,” the Reserve Bank of New Zealand said.
“However, we identified opportunities to build on this resilience through stronger risk management and recovery planning.
“Participating insurers will be provided with written feedback on insurer-specific observations and broader industry themes.
“We will monitor insurers’ progress with implementing recommendations as part of our ongoing stress testing engagements.”
A reverse stress test starts with a severe adverse outcome and works backwards to identify the events that could cause it.
“This differs from a traditional stress test, in which all participating insurers assess the effects of the same scenario,” RBNZ said. “Allowing insurers to develop scenarios around their own businesses helped identify vulnerabilities that a common scenario might miss.
“It also showed how several risks could interact and build over time to cause a solvency breach.”
See the test report here.