Insurer ordered to reveal ‘confidential’ tip-off details
A man fighting for a $400,000 total and permanent disability payout has won access to communications and internal documents concerning a whistleblower that his insurer argued were confidential.
MLC – now known as Acenda – said the communications were a “protected confidence” under the NSW Evidence Act, which concerns professional relationships in which confidentiality is integral, such as those of health professionals, social workers and private investigators.
But the NSW Supreme Court has ruled the communications and documents in this case are not protected confidences.
Justice Francois Kunc says the “confider” did “no more than provide certain information to MLC”, and there was no relationship where MLC was acting in a professional capacity.
MLC initially accepted Christopher Preuss’ TPD claim in August 2023. But after receiving a tip-off that he was working while supposedly disabled, the insurer reopened its assessment and in April 2024 it sought declarations that it did not have to pay the claim.
The source of the tip-off – or confider – had asked for their name to be kept confidential.
Mr Preuss began proceedings in 2023 and in December 2024 issued MLC with a notice to produce its claims file.
The insurer produced documents with redactions, masking communications it said were protected.
The court had to consider if harm might be caused to a protected confider if evidence was provided.
Justice Kunc says that in 2022 Mr Preuss’ ex-wife emailed his lawyers about fraud, asking to remain anonymous.
The lawyers produced the email, saying if it was assumed that Ms Preuss was the confider, Mr Preuss was already aware of her conduct, which made any harm from disclosure of the communications unlikely.
Find the judgment here.