Brought to you by:

Broker more right than wrong in claims row: AFCA

A broker has been told to pay $700 and apologise to clients for repeated information requests, but the industry ombudsman has rejected a raft of other complaints against it.

JDI (Young) arranged policies with different insurers for the customers, who later complained about claim delays, the repeated requests for details, inadequate advocacy and unclear advice about a written-off vehicle.

The clients wanted $5000 compensation for stress, inconvenience and time lost.

They said they were asked to provide the same information several times over a six-week period, had to deal directly with a repairer over an issue and eventually took over management of outstanding claims themselves.

They also complained the broker did not explain what would happen to the registration and insurance of a vehicle declared a total loss. The clients continued driving the car and were stopped by police while it was unregistered.

The broker said it “lodged the claims promptly, regularly followed up with the insurers and communicated the total loss decision as soon as it was received”.

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority accepts that repeated requests for information already supplied would have been frustrating, and the broker should have checked its records before asking the clients to provide the information again.

Regarding the police incident, AFCA backs the broker, finding it warned the clients against driving the vehicle and had explained that it needed to obtain further information about its status.

The broker could not provide definitive advice about registration and insurance until the relevant details were confirmed.

“While I accept being made aware the registration was cancelled after being stopped by police caused stress, I am not persuaded the broker was responsible for this,” an AFCA member said.

The ombudsman says the broker was generally responsive to the clients’ requests and contacts, and dissatisfaction with response times or the content of replies alone does not justify compensation.

It says $700 compensation is fair for the inconvenience caused by the repeated information requests.

See the ruling here.