Aunty matter produces right and wrong reactions
An insurer must pay $500 compensation over a delayed response and “lack of compassion in its communications” when rejecting a claim because its policyholder’s terminally ill aunt was not deemed immediate family.
The insured was unable to attend an event because he had to travel overseas to see his aunt – a “parental figure” who had helped raise him.
He claimed under an event ticket refund protection policy with Cover Genius, but the claim was declined because an aunt did not meet the definition of immediate family.
The policyholder argued the definition was too restrictive and did not reflect modern family structures or the close relationship he had with his aunt.
He also complained the insurer’s claim handling caused loss and distress. He submitted his claim on December 19 last year but did not get a decision until December 29, after the event he was missing had begun.
He said the insurer’s website stated it would respond to claims within five days, and an earlier response might have allowed him to sell or transfer his event tickets.
| Related article: Mustang dally – driver compensated over long road to repair |
In a dispute ruling, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority says the policy specifically limited cover to illness or death of the policyholder, another event ticket-holder or an immediate family member.
The definition included parents, children, spouses, partners and live-in siblings or dependants, plus equivalent step-family living with the policyholder.
AFCA says it would not be fair to require Cover Genius to extend its insurance beyond the terms agreed. It also finds insufficient evidence the delay caused a financial loss, because there was no guarantee the tickets could have been sold and it was not known how much they might have fetched.
But the policy “required the complainant to provide the original unused and operable ticket, which the financial firm could then cancel or resell at its discretion. This meant the complainant could not decide whether to sell or transfer the tickets until he received the claim decision.”
An AFCA member says this “lost opportunity, together with the financial firm’s acknowledged failure to meet its service level and lack of compassion in its communications, caused more than the usual inconvenience expected in a claim”.
It has ordered the insurer to increase its $200 compensation offer to $500.
See the ruling here.