IAG tipped to face court battle over RAC deal
Competition watchdog approval for IAG’s takeover of RAC Insurance looks unlikely and court processes to win clearance could extend well into next year, JP Morgan says.
IAG has made additional commitments to persuade the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission to clear the deal after it opposed it in September.
But an ACCC preliminary assessment last week said the public benefits of the proposed transaction are unlikely to outweigh negative impacts. It has given the insurer until December 1 to respond and will make a final decision by February 1.
“If there was a negative ruling, as now seems likely to us, IAG could go to court, which we believe would typically take six months,” JP Morgan said, based on the timetable for ANZ’s acquisition of Suncorp’s bank.
IAG and RAC have indicated they will take their case to the Australian Competition Tribunal if the ACCC continues to oppose the deal.
JP Morgan says some of the public benefits advocated by IAG may have been underappreciated, given the corporate and prudential regulators have raised concerns with the sector on claims servicing capabilities during extreme weather, cyber risk and the need for up-to-date policy systems.
“It is possible, in our view, that a court could take a different view to the ACCC given sufficient compelling evidence of these benefits,” JP Morgan says.
IAG says it remains confident the strategic alliance will deliver long-term benefits for customers and communities across WA, and it “disagrees with the preliminary view” of the regulator.
The insurer says it will “continue to engage constructively as the process progresses”, and RAC has also reiterated support.
“RAC continues to believe the proposed partnership would create long-term benefits for our members, our people and the WA community, and we welcome the opportunity for these benefits to be assessed alongside competition considerations,” it said.