Brought to you by:

Industry ‘must stamp out’ smash repair fraud

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google

Rogue panelbeaters are charging insurers inflated bills for repair work that is, in many cases, deliberately engineered, according to industry experts.

LMI Group MD Allan Manning wants action to tackle the problem, which will affect premium affordability if left unchecked.

“As an industry, we have to stamp it out,” he told “If we are paying fraudulent claims, it’s just another form of organised crime.

“It is staged accidents… they are making good money out of it.”

In one case involving an LMI employee, a panelbeater offered to recommend a workshop if the man wanted some “damage” caused to his utility vehicle, for the purpose of making an insurance claim.

“The whole thing is well known in the panelbeating industry,” Professor Manning says. “The whole situation is taking the sheen off the panelbeating industry and tarnishing the reputation of the many good folk who own and work in it.

“It certainly needs to be addressed by the insurance industry and the police as soon as possible.”

The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA), citing a report by the Consumer Action Law Centre advocacy group, says the problem extends beyond panelbeaters.

“Behaviour by some replacement car hire firms, recovery agents, law firms and smash repairers… can cause confusion, distress and inconvenience to motorists, and push up the cost of insurance for all policyholders,” ICA GM Communications and Media Relations Campbell Fuller told

“ICA is raising these concerns with relevant regulators. ICA also works to educate motorists about their rights and responsibilities in the aftermath of vehicle accidents, to avoid them agreeing to services that may not be covered by insurance, and might result in financial losses and delays in getting their vehicle returned.”

Melbourne private investigator Peter Hiscock, who has worked on such cases for insurers, says racketeering is “massively under-reported”.

“It’s not related to just small individual panel shops,” he told “It may be related to chains of panel shops.”

The Consumer Action Law Centre raised similar concerns in May. It says the problem is partly due to car insurers’ measures to contain spiralling repair costs.

“As insurance companies squeeze the profits of car repairers, a business opportunity has opened up for lawyers to help repairers increase their profits, but the system cannot work without the involvement of the customer/client,” the law centre says.

“Unfortunately, too many clients don’t know what they have agreed to until it’s too late.”